When it comes to easels and painting outside (also known as plein air), finding the perfect easels for the outdoors can be a challenge. When it comes to plein-air painting, two popular options are the French easel and the pochade box easel. While both are designed for outdoor use, they have some clear differences that can make one more suitable for your needs than the other. In French easel vs pochade box easel, let’s explore the differences, pros, and cons of both easels.
Let’s define what each is.
What is a French easel?
A French easel is a traditional, three-legged easel that typically comes with a built-in palette and storage for art supplies. It can be adjusted to different heights and angles, making it a versatile tool for painting outdoors or in the studio.
What is a Pochard box?
A pochade box easel is a portable, box-like device that holds your painting surface and art supplies. It usually includes a small tripod to support the box while you work, and can be attached to a larger tripod for additional stability.
Now, let’s compare the two options in a table based on their key attributes as easels and useability:
| French Easel | Pochade Box | |
|---|---|---|
| Size and weight | Large and a little heavy but still portable. Not like a studio easel. The average size of a French easel varies depending on the specific model, but most French easels are designed to hold canvases up to 32 inches in height. When folded, a typical French easel is about 24 inches by 18 inches by 6 inches. When fully extended and set up for use, a French easel can be as tall as 70 inches. Keep in mind that there are many different French easel models available, so the size can vary depending on the specific brand and design. | Small and lightweight, very portable. The average size of a pochade box easel also varies depending on the specific model, but most pochade boxes are designed to hold canvases up to 16-18 inches in height. When closed, a typical pochade box easel is about 12 inches by 16 inches by 3 inches. When fully extended and set up for use, a pochade box easel can be as tall as 30 inches. However, keep in mind that like French easels, there are many different pochade box models available, so the size can vary depending on the specific brand and design. |
| Storage capacity | Spacious | Limited |
| Set-up time | Longer (around 5 to 10 minutes) | Shorter (Up and running in less than 5 minutes) |
| Stability | Stable, but can be affected by wind as it is light weight but not as light as pochade box easel | Less stable than a French easel. I like to weigh mine down when I am using one |
| Versatility | Can be used indoors and outdoors, adjustable | Best for outdoor use, limited adjustability |
French Easel
If you have never seen a French easel before, have a look at the (clickable image takes you to Amazon) image below. See the various compartments, drawers and how the legs are angled as they are usually attached to the base of the drawer rather than pivoting on a joint.
Pochade Box
If you have never seen a Pochade box easel before, have a look at the (clickable image takes you to Amazon) image below. See the various compartments, drawers and how the legs are angled and can pivot at the base where they join the box.
One of the main differences between a French easel and a pochade box easel is size and weight. French easels tend to be larger and heavier, making them more difficult to transport but I would not say an impossibility, they are just heavier than a smaller easel that is all. On the other hand, pochade boxes are typically more compact and lightweight, making them easier to carry with you on the go.
Another factor to consider is storage capacity. French easels usually have more room for art supplies, which is important if you need to carry a large number of materials with you. Pochade boxes, on the other hand, have limited storage space, but can still hold the essentials for plein air painting.
Set-up time is also an important consideration. French easels can take longer to set up, as you need to adjust the legs and angle the canvas. Pochade boxes, on the other hand, are quicker to set up, as you simply need to attach the box to the tripod and adjust the canvas holder.
Stability is another important factor to consider
French easels are generally more stable than pochade boxes, as they have three legs and are more resistant to wind. However, pochade boxes can still provide a stable painting surface when attached to a tripod.
Finally, versatility is also important to consider. French easels can be used both indoors and outdoors, and are adjustable to different angles and heights. Pochade boxes are best suited for outdoor use, but can still be used indoors if you attach them to a larger tripod. However, they are limited in terms of adjustability.
Now that we’ve compared the two options, let’s explore the pros and cons of each.
French Easel Pros:
- Spacious storage capacity
- Stable painting surface
- Adjustable to different angles and heights
- Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
French Easel Cons:
- Large and heavy, making it difficult to transport
- Longer set-up time
- More expensive than pochade boxes
Pochade Box Pros:
- Lightweight and compact, making it easy to transport
- Quick set-up time
- Affordable
- Ideal for outdoor use
Pochade Box Cons:
- Limited storage capacity
- Less stable than a French easel, especially in windy conditions
- Limited adjustability
So, which one should you choose?
If you prioritize portability and quick set-up time, a pochade box easel is likely the better option for you. It is ideal for artists who don’t need to carry a large number of supplies with them and prefer to work in outdoor settings. Pochade boxes are also a more affordable option, making them a good choice for artists on a budget.
On the other hand, if you need more storage space for your supplies and prefer a stable painting surface, a French easel may be the better option for you. French easels are also a good choice if you work both indoors and outdoors, and if you don’t mind carrying around a heavier, bulkier option.
It’s worth noting that some artists may prefer to use both a French easel and a pochade box easel, depending on their needs. For example, you could use a pochade box easel for quick outdoor sketches, and a French easel for more extended outdoor painting sessions or indoor studio work.
Personally, I like the French easel for smaller paintings (I use a large studio easel for my big canvases). The French easel lets me throw all my stuff into the drawers and I can carry it around and set up quite quickly. I am sure I would come to love the pochade box easel given the time I needed with it.
I have found a few models online that may suit your needs but please go into an art store and see for yourself as these tools need to be seen in person to ensure they suit your height and other needs.
Other notable Plein Air easels to consider
While we have been comparing the French easel vs Pochade box, if you need to look at other easel options there are plenty more that may suit your needs have a look at the links below:
A Drafting Table Or Easel? What’s Best For Artists
The Best Easel Alternatives That Don’t Cost A Fortune
French easel vs pochade box Easel – wrap up!
French easel vs pochade box easel, this is not an easy choice to make without seeing both in person and looking at them up close. Choosing between a French easel and a pochade box easel depends on your personal needs and preferences as an artist.
Both options have their pros and cons, and it’s important to consider factors such as size, weight, storage capacity, set-up time, stability, and versatility when making your decision. By doing so, you’ll be able to find the perfect tool for your plein-air painting adventures.
